Spreadsheets, inbox, shouting. Honestly compared.
For teams with no tool yet, wondering whether they need one.
This page is ours, so it is not neutral. That is why it also says when you should stay with your spreadsheets, which is more often than we would like.
Guido Boyke, founder
What spreadsheets do well
No rollout, no training, no meeting where someone explains a new tool to the team.
A spreadsheet imposes no workflow, so it fits every one. That is its strength, as long as the workflow fits in two heads.
Nobody has to learn how to insert a row, and nobody refuses to.
The comparison in detail
This means the usual mix of spreadsheet, inbox and shouting across the room, not one particular program. Teams who keep their sheets in strict order get further than these rows suggest.
| Question | Spreadsheet and inbox | Lalabase | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who does what | A name in a column, current if someone maintains it | Assignment on the ticket, to several people if needed, with history | Lalabase ahead |
| What is the state of this | Whoever saved last knows | On the ticket, with time and person | Lalabase ahead |
| How many hours was that | A second sheet, pieced together at month's end | Recorded on the ticket, billable per session | Lalabase ahead |
| Where is the documentation | A folder of files, state unclear | From the repository, with the commit it came from | Lalabase ahead |
| What was said in the client call | Notebook, inbox, or memory | An object of its own with transcript, summary and derived tasks | Lalabase ahead |
| What does the client see | Whatever you send them, when you remember to | An account with read rights, taking no paid seat | Lalabase ahead |
| Where was that again | Search inside the file that happens to be open | One question across every source, answered with sources | Lalabase ahead |
| Two people at once | File locked, or two versions appear | Everyone in the same project, changes traceable | Lalabase ahead |
| Someone is away | The state sits in that person's head | The state sits on the task | Lalabase ahead |
| Data protection towards your clients | Yours to handle, paperwork included | Hosting in Germany, data processing agreement included | Lalabase ahead |
| What it costs | Nothing extra, you already have the program | Subscription, tiered by team size | Spreadsheet and inbox ahead |
| Getting started | None, anyone can insert a row | About an hour, then it runs | Spreadsheet and inbox ahead |
When you should stay with spreadsheets
There are two of you on one project and you talk daily anyway. Then a tool answers a question you do not have.
Nobody asks you for a state you do not already know. The value starts where being asked costs time, and not before.
Your clients want an invoice and a result, not an account. Then you are paying for doors nobody uses.
What is in there comes along.
Send your sheet and you get back a set-up environment with your real projects, instead of clicking through demo data.
Talk about the sheetAs a file, exactly as it is. Messy is fine, we have seen worse.
Projects, tasks, statuses and the fields you actually use. By hand, not by an assistant that guesses half of it wrong.
At your own material rather than at demo data. If it does not fit, you have lost nothing but the time for one email.
See it rather than believe it.
Create an account, drop in your own sheet, and see whether it gets better.